WSIB Claims Management and HR Assistance for Employers
  • About
  • Services
    • Disability Management >
      • WSIB Claims Management
      • WSIB Appeals
      • STD Claims Adjudication
      • Medical Management
      • The WSIB's NEER Program
    • HR On-Demand >
      • Employee Policy Book
    • Legislation Compliance >
      • DIY Packages
      • AODA Legislation >
        • Integrated Accessibility Standard Regulation >
          • DIY Package AODA Integrated Standard >
            • Samples DIY AODA Integrated Standard Package
        • Customer Service Standard >
          • AODA CSS Requirements
          • DIY Package AODA Customer Service Standard >
            • Samples DIY AODA Customer Service Standard Package
      • Harassment, Violence, and Sexual Harassment Legislation >
        • DIY Package Bill 168
        • Samples DIY Bill 168 Package
    • Health & Safety Solutions >
      • Auditing Your Program
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • About
  • Services
    • Disability Management >
      • WSIB Claims Management
      • WSIB Appeals
      • STD Claims Adjudication
      • Medical Management
      • The WSIB's NEER Program
    • HR On-Demand >
      • Employee Policy Book
    • Legislation Compliance >
      • DIY Packages
      • AODA Legislation >
        • Integrated Accessibility Standard Regulation >
          • DIY Package AODA Integrated Standard >
            • Samples DIY AODA Integrated Standard Package
        • Customer Service Standard >
          • AODA CSS Requirements
          • DIY Package AODA Customer Service Standard >
            • Samples DIY AODA Customer Service Standard Package
      • Harassment, Violence, and Sexual Harassment Legislation >
        • DIY Package Bill 168
        • Samples DIY Bill 168 Package
    • Health & Safety Solutions >
      • Auditing Your Program
  • Contact
  • Blog

Victory for Transfer-of-Cost Employers with WSIB

10/12/2015

0 Comments

 
Victory
​Clear Path recently challenged what could be considered a precedent-setting decision from the Workplace Safety & Insurance Board (WSIB) that would have put certain employers at a serious disadvantage.
 
Our red flags went up after we received a decision from a WSIB SIEF Case Manager denying our ability to request cost relief for a client who was a Transfer-of-Cost (TOC) employer. The reason? According to the WSIB, the TOC employer is not granted the right to even request SIEF because they are a TOC employer. Why? Due to the Board's disclosure (privacy) policies!

As a result of our objections, we brought this issue forward to senior management at the Board and we were ultimately able to get the SIEF team to review their interpretation of its disclosure policy, acknowledging that TOC employers satisfied the definition of an employer and are therefore entitled to request SIEF cost relief when applicable.
 
What is a Transfer-of-Cost (TOC) employer?
 
In the event that one company’s employee is injured at another company’s location or as a result of the actions of another company, responsibility for WSIB claim costs may be transferred to the “at fault” company.
 
What is SIEF cost relief?
 
The WSIB offers cost relief to employers through their Secondary Injury Enhancement Fund (SIEF) when they have an injured employee who has a pre-existing condition that enhances or prolongs the work-related injury or delays the worker’s recovery. Two important considerations about SIEF:
  • When applying for SIEF cost relief it is standard to receive a copy of the injured worker’s “access file” which contains relevant medical details that will be used to determine whether or not there is a relevant pre-existing condition.
  • As part of its strategy to reduce its “unfunded liability,” the WSIB has been much more conservative in approving SIEF cost relief requests from employers in recent years.
 
Details 
  • A client (“Company A”) had been deemed a TOC employer after a “Company B” employee had been injured on their property. The WSIB deemed “Company A” financially responsible for the injury and therefore for the worker’s WSIB claim costs. 
  • Upon investigation into the claim, Clear Path sought SIEF cost relief for "Company A" as we believed the worker may have had a pre-existing condition that prolonged the worker’s recovery.  In response, we received a reply from the SIEF Team at WSIB: “Company A” was not entitled to even request cost relief because “Company A” was a TOC employer.
  • The SIEF Department relied on its interpretation of Disclosure policies, 21-02-02 and 21-02-03.  According to their interpretation of policy 21-02-03 [Disclosure of Claim Information to Employers (No Issue in Dispute)], TOC employers are not permitted to request SIEF, but rather may only request limited claim information without an initial issue in dispute. 
  • What this meant was that a TOC employer could not request SIEF because the case manager would not be able to tell the TOC employer why they may have denied SIEF because the TOC employer was not entitled to certain details of the claim that are typically provided during the SIEF process.  To Clear Path, not only was this faulty logic, it was also an unfair interpretation that placed TOC employers at a disadvantage.
 
Clear Path’s argument
 
After obtaining an interpretation from WSIB’s own policy department and several attempts to discuss this with the SIEF Team without success, we brought this matter to the attention of WSIB’s Chief Operating Officer John Slinger.  We expressed our concern regarding the application of the SIEF Department’s unfair interpretation of disclosure policies, in essence advising that the TOC employer bears the cost of the claim and should be entitled to pursue cost relief if applicable. 
 
By way of argument, we noted: “Regardless of whether there is an issue in dispute, a TOC employer is still required to bear the financial outcome of a claim.  Therefore to deny a request for SIEF is a denial of natural justice.  As such, this office finds WSIB’s reliance on disclosure policies as a way of baring requests for SIEF to be a prejudicial and irresponsible practice that denies TOC Employers effective participation in the decision-making process.”
 
Ultimately, the WSIB agreed!
 
Approximately four weeks after submitting the letter, we received a response from the Director of the SIEF Team on behalf of Mr. Slinger, which stated, “…in [cases] where a TOC employer has received a notice of decision (not a full decision letter), but nevertheless wishes to object to the decision itself, the decision making practices… requires that the TOC employer be provided with a copy of the actual decision letter, including reasons, findings of fact and evidence.  This is so the TOC employer can meaningfully participate in the discussion/reconsideration process with the case manager and exercise their right to have the decision reviewed by the Appeals Resolution Officer if they so choose.”
 
Bringing it all together
 
For those professionals who regularly deal with claims and are familiar with WSIB policy and procedures, it is clear why this issue is fundamentally important as it relates to not only SIEF cost relief but in the entire decision-making practice. 
 
While participating in claims management it is important to remember the following:
  • Do not be afraid to question a case manager’s decision! Case managers are not omnipotent; they are people who can make mistakes just like everyone else.  If you are provided with a decision that requires clarification or you altogether disagree, request written clarification and do not be afraid to object and escalate if necessary!
  • Become familiar with WSIB’s policies and adjudicative practices. Without having at least some knowledge of policy it may be difficult to recognize those decisions that may require reconsideration.  Case Managers will often quote policy that support their decisions. Read these policies to fully understand the case manager’s logic and do not be afraid to speak with other departments, specifically the policy department, for clarification.
  • Recognize if a claim has become too complicated!  If you do not have the resources or experience to handle a claim that may have multiple issues at hand, seek help from the experts before your company may negatively be impacted! 
 
Are you experiencing difficulties with a WSIB claim? Book a no obligation consultation with Clear Path's Anna Aceto-Guerin for some expert advice.


We'd love to connect with you! 
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    AODA
    Bill 168/Workplace Violence
    Clear Path
    Equality
    Events/Occasions
    Health & Safety
    Hiring/Firing
    HR Topics
    Mental Health & Wellness
    NEER
    Policies
    Social Media
    WSIAT
    WSIB

    Archives

    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    November 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012

Clear Path Employer Services
295 Thompson Drive, Unit 2
Cambridge, Ontario  N1T 2B9

T:  (519) 624-0800
T:  (888) 336-0950
F:  (519) 624-0860
E:  info@clearpathemployer.com
Website created by:
Absolutely Business
Copyright 2017
Staying Connected:
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe  to our Emails
  • Careers/Job Openings ​
 Services:
  • ​WSIB/WCB Claims Management
  • HR on Demand​
  • Workplace Health & Safety
  • Legislation Compliance​​​
​ Hear More About Us: 
  • Testimonials
​Spread the Word:
  • ​Referral Program
​Policies and Information:​
  • Privacy Statement
  • Terms and Conditions​​